This could be a 10/10 contender, but some flaws hold it back for now. Let's see...
The good:
- The visuals and style are absolutely amazing. The girls are super cute, the environments are detailed, and the UI is great as well!
- The animations are superb. Believable motion, nothing rigid, the camera even shakes in sync with the thrusts. The facial animations don't quite meet those high standards though.
- The audio design is pretty good, with fitting music and plenty of SFX (very little SFX during the lewd scene though...)
- The moment-to-moment writing is nice, it's well-paced, no noticeable typos, and it's always clear what's happening (some newbie devs struggle with that sometimes)
- The dev tries something new by having only 3 romanceable LIs, plus 3 "temptresses" associated with each of them, who can lock you out of the respective romance path if you indulge too much. However, so far this is just a concept and not at all implemented. Though I like the flower analogies that the romance system uses.
- The game uses plenty of references to Japanese culture and there's always a small explanation in case you're unfamiliar. Nice!
The bad:
- The story barely went anywhere so far. There isn't really a challenge presented that the MC has to overcome, it has basically been just character introductions. As of now the story was and is kinda boring.
- The girls are silly. Often it's charming, other times kinda annoying.
- There's just one lewd scene so far. Not a problem for me, but you might think otherwise.
- During that one lewd scene the MC is a straight up asshole. You could even make a reasonable case that he committed sexual a****** twice. In the end the girl wasn't too upset with him, but still, I'm not a fan.
- Another complaint for the lewd scene: During it, the text slowly fades in, which makes the scene annoying to go through if you're a fast reader.
- And another complaint for the lewd scene: When the MC finishes, there's just a single black frame. It's like there's a render missing? Idk, but that part of the scene in particular could be better too.
So, overall an amazing start for a newbie dev, though I see plenty of room for improvement. Still, the dev tries something new and I'm always happy to see that!
Overall: 8/10
Visuals: 10/10
Audio & Animations: 9/10
Characters: 8/10
Story: 6/10
Lewd Content: 4/10