Well, I can't say I totally disagree but I do feel like there are certain times where the MC needs to say something. When I first started making the game I made the decision that the MC would talk and react to the events happening because it would be weird if they just stood there with no reaction not saying anything. But after a few years I started cutting back on how often the MC actually says anything and now I'm leaning toward having someone in the party (assuming they were recruited) say something instead. I prefer to not have the MC speak because it's more work to think of something for them to say and have it be neutral enough that it could work with any of the character options you choose. So basically the early stuff I worked on always had the MC talk, but over the past year I've mostly stopped adding dialogue for them unless I feel like something needs to be said. I guess another option would be having others say something as if the MC said something, and just leaving it up to players to decide what would've been said.
I've been wanting to do a poll on the Discord server to see what everyone prefers because I don't want to remove the MC talking completely if it ends up being preferred. I've just been waiting for more people to join so that more people will have a say. I'll definitely run the poll before releasing the paid version of the game though.
Viewing post in Thoughts/suggestions
I mean, that's fair, but it just... really takes me out of the experience when I go through the trouble of creating an MC only for them to yap and say things I wouldn't say. I dunno, I just prefer letting me, the player react to the world through character actions. I'm totally fine with party members and NPCs chatting and talking to me. And I like dialogue options but I just... NEVER liked when the MC themselves talked. I mean, it's a little different when the character exists in the world already and it's a totally character driven story. Like, the difference between SMT/Persona and Xenoblade or Final Fantasy. I just prefer the former to the latter kind of RPG experiences overall. I guess, I myself want to be in the story vs watching/guiding someone else's story. That kinda mindset.
Now, I prefer silent protagonists and dialogue options if to let the player speak. But well, that's just me. A few games take the middle of the road appraoch but those are more hits than misses....