Hi, did you manage to get this resolved? I saw your update thanking them for restoring indexing, followed by another issue after changing the thumbnail. Are your games searchable again now, and did support explain what caused it or what fixed it?
I’m having a similar problem: only my first game appears in itch.io search, while all my other projects are missing, even when searching their exact titles. I emailed support a few days ago but haven’t heard back yet. Any advice from your experience would help.